Medical series have been among the most popular types of shows on television for decades now. Part of this success can be credited to ER, a series that chronicled the stories of doctors working at the County General Hospital in Chicago. The show featured a talented leading cast including Anthony Edwards, George Clooney, Eriq La Salle, Julianna Margulies, and Noah Wyle. ER was an extremely well-regarded show, winning 23 Emmys over the course of its 15 seasons. Over the years, a revival of ER has been floated, but it has never gotten off the ground.
Taking the place of ER in the land of the top-tier medical procedural was Grey’s Anatomy. The series had some overlap, as Grey’s Anatomy began in 2005, three years before ER‘s ending in 2008. Grey’s Anatomy is still running today, and has led to spinoffs as well as a rise in medical TV shows. Two such series came late last year, including the Ryan Murphy show Doctor Odyssey as well as the NBC comedy St. Denis Medical. Now, another new medical series that features an ER actor gets reviewed by an actual doctor.
The Pitt’s Accuracy Is Under Review By A Real Doctor
And The Results Are Positive
The Pitt‘s accuracy is reviewed by a real-life doctor. The Max original series features ER‘s John Carter actor, Noah Wyle, this time putting him into the lead role. This time, the series’ setting is in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, chronicling Dr. Michael Robinavitch and his co-workers as they attempt to treat critically ill patients. The Pitt aired its first two episodes early this year, on Thursday, January 9, and will continue episodes weekly on Thursdays through April 10.
Now, Doctor Mike reviews the accuracy of The Pitt, evaluating the claim that it is the “most accuracte medical series of all time.”
The doctor complimented everything from the introduction to the residents and interns to the level to which the ERs are overwhelmed. The actual medical issues in The Pitt were also deemed accurate, including the portrayal of burns and the treatment of ailments. Doctor Mike also appreciated how the series shows statistics related to a hospital’s performance. The show was so accurate at points that the doctor even felt it to be “too real.”
Our Take On The Pitt’s Accuracy Analysis
This Is Even More Positive Press For The Pitt
Given the accuracy of The Pitt‘s portrayal of its medical issues, it is good to see how well this show has been doing so far. The show is regularly topping the Max charts, with its episodes sustaining strong viewership rates. Furthermore, The Pitt is getting great reviews, getting a Certified Fresh 93% Tomatometer on Rotten Tomatoes and a 78% Popcornmeter among fans. Evaluations like that of Doctor Mike only further add to The Pitt‘s clout, which is a hopeful sign for the future of the series.
Source: Doctor Mike / YouTube

The Pitt
- Release Date
-
January 9, 2025
- Network
-
Max
- Showrunner
-
R. Scott Gemmill
- Directors
-
Amanda Marsalis