Prime Video’s New 8-Half Crime Thriller Primarily based On Bestsellers Is Dividing Critics & Audiences On Rotten Tomatoes

Scarpetta, Nicole Kidman’s new crime thriller on Prime Video, was launched on March 11, however it’s already proving to be divisive.

Whereas the TV drama is Licensed Recent on Rotten Tomatoes with a critic rating of 76%, the viewers rating is presently sitting at 51%, a pointy 25% distinction. The viewers rating on the Popcornmeter hasn’t reached the minimal 60% threshold to be thought-about Sizzling, which implies viewers have given Scarpetta a Stale score.

Whereas critics have taken problem with sure points of the collection, just like the storyline’s climax and the complicated backstory, a lot of them claimed that Scarpetta is sort of a page-turner, which is sensible contemplating the present is predicated on Patricia Cornwell’s Kay Scarpetta novels.

In addition they praised Kidman’s uncooked efficiency because the titular pathologist/medical expert, and her and Jamie Lee Curtis’ chemistry collectively.

Viewers reactions have not been as variety, although. They known as it slow-moving, cringe-worthy and disjointed. Viewers who’ve learn Cornwell’s books weren’t glad with the variation, saying that Scarpetta is not devoted to the creator’s work. Among the unfavorable opinions claimed, with out proof, that the collection is simply too woke.

The constructive viewers opinions, alternatively, lavished reward on Scarpetta for its writing, casting and surprising twists.

Cornwell has written virtually 30 novels in her Kay Scarpetta collection, with the primary one printed in 1990 and the newest one in 2025. She serves as an government producer on the Prime Video collection alongside showrunner Liz Sarnoff, Blumhouse’s Jason Blum, Kidman, Curtis, Per Saari, David Gordon Inexperienced, Chris Dickie, Jeremy Gold, Chris McCumber and Amy Sayres.

Bobby Cannavale, Simon Baker and Ariana DeBose star with Kidman and Curtis on Scarpetta, a criminal offense collection that facilities on Kidman’s titular character as she helps clear up crimes whereas additionally revisiting a case from early in her profession. Curtis performs her sister, Dorothy Scarpetta.

Prime Video is already shifting ahead with Scarpetta season 2, which can adapt Merciless and Uncommon and The Physique Farm, the fourth and fifth books in Cornwell’s collection, after the primary season coated the occasions of Postmortem and Post-mortem.

Whereas Kidman has made a reputation for herself as a film star after showing in such movies as Sensible Magic, Moulin Rouge! and The Stepford Wives, she has discovered a number of success on the small display screen lately, on exhibits like Massive Little Lies, The Undoing, 9 Good Strangers and The Good Couple.

Her newest collection could also be divisive on Rotten Tomatoes, with largely constructive opinions from critics and mixed-to-negative reactions from audiences, however Prime Video seems to imagine in Scarpetta because the streaming platform already ordered two seasons again in 2024.

Scarpetta season 1 is out there to stream on Prime Video.