Ridley Scott argues that he directed a greater pro-female film than Thelma & Louise. The 1991 movie is broadly thought-about to be one in every of Ridley Scott’s finest motion pictures and has acquired in depth essential approval for its feminist messages. It follows the titular finest associates, performed by Geena Davis and Susan Sarandon, whose street journey takes a darkish flip and forces them to take determined measures.
Regardless of this, Scott shared with Letterboxd that he believes his 1997 struggle film G.I. Jane, starring Demi Moore, is the perfect pro-female film ever made, even when in comparison with Thelma & Louise. He additionally discusses Moore’s efficiency within the 2024 horror film The Substance and says that he thinks the author and director Coralie Fargeat “misplaced management of it.” Take a look at Scott’s feedback under:
After all. The Substance, from the director’s perspective, is an excellent huge Kubrickian concept. In the event you actually need me to say what I feel, [Coralie Fargeat] type of misplaced management of it. That finish scene, the place they sprayed the room with blood, they merely didn’t know what to do. However I feel it was a courageous concept concerning the illness of facelifts and altering your look. By no means change your look, simply keep match. As a result of you possibly can all the time inform. With Demi, we made a really, superb movie with G.I. Jane. I feel it’s the finest pro-women movie actually ever made, even higher than Thelma & Louise.
Take into consideration what she does. And never solely that—the unhealthy man’s Anne Bancroft, who assumes you’re going to lose. Are you kidding me?
Scott is understood for being candid, however his assertion that G.I. Jane is best than Thelma & Louise nonetheless comes as a shock. The Geena Davis and Susan Sarandon film was added to the Nationwide Movie Registry by the Library of Congress in 2016 and is taken into account a feminist traditional. The American Movie Institute additionally added it to their checklist of 100 all-time most inspiring motion pictures in 2006.
Together with these prestigious accomplishments, Thelma & Louise acquired six Academy Award nominations. Scott, Davis, and Sarandon have been all nominated and Callie Khouri received for Greatest Unique Screenplay. 34 years later, it holds an 87% essential rating and 82% viewers rating on Rotten Tomatoes.
In the meantime, G.I. Jane has a 55% essential rating and 53% viewers rating and didn’t obtain the type of acclaim or awards recognition that Thelma & Louise did. As a substitute of an Academy Award nomination, Moore received the Razzie Award for Worst Actress for her G.I. Jane efficiency.
Moore performs Lieutenant Jordan O’Neil, the primary girl chosen to develop into a Navy SEAL. O’Neil works laborious to show herself and to command the respect of her navy commander, John James Urgayle (Viggo Mortensen). It is a totally different method to a feminist story than Thelma & Louise, the place the titular characters finally reply to nobody however themselves as they develop into outlaws.
Whereas Scott’s opinion is unconventional, he makes use of what the character of O’Neil achieves to make his argument, together with the formidable villain that she faces in Anne Bancroft’s Senator Lillian DeHaven. He additionally comes from the attitude of directing G.I. Jane after Thelma & Louise and having advanced as a filmmaker.