The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum seems to be set to repeat a mistake of Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit trilogy. So far as Lord of the Rings rankings go, many are inclined to agree that the Hobbit films usually are not on the identical stage as the unique trilogy. They definitely have their deserves, however some errors have been made.
Nonetheless, upcoming Lord of the Rings films appear to be returning to live-action filmmaking for the primary time since what is usually thought of the worst Hobbit film, The Battle of the 5 Armies, in 2014. The order of Lord of the Rings films is about to have a brand new addition, nestled between the occasions of The Fellowship of the Ring.
That story is The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum, a film directed by and starring Andy Serkis because the titular character. The film will likely be launched in December 2027 and is seemingly set to star a number of returning actors from the unique Lord of the Rings trilogy. Regardless of the thrill surrounding this, it may very well be repeating certainly one of The Hobbit‘s key errors.
The Hunt For Gollum Is Relying On Too A lot Authentic Trilogy Nostalgia
The error The Hunt for Gollum could also be making is banking an excessive amount of on nostalgia for the unique Lord of the Rings trilogy. The Hobbit suffered from this to an extent, with many feeling as if the tie-ins to the unique Lord of the Rings films have been compelled and unearned.
A number of moments from The Hobbit felt like this, notably the point out of Aragorn to Legolas with out really saying his identify in The Battle of the 5 Armies or the opening of An Surprising Journey starring Elijah Wooden and Ian Holm. In The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum, this sense may return.
The movie is already confirmed to function Andy Serkis, with Ian McKellen just lately confirming that Gandalf and Frodo will likely be in The Hunt for Gollum. Whereas it was not revealed whether or not McKellen and Wooden will reprise their roles, the characters have a minimum of been cemented within the film.
Though it does make sense for Gandalf to be within the film, in addition to Serkis’ Gollum, it appears as if Frodo’s return – and the general pivot again to unique trilogy characters after the considerably unique Conflict of the Rohirrim – is a nostalgic play.
One other Lord Of The Rings Film Proves The Franchise’s Mistake
To additional show how Lord of the Rings is counting on nostalgia going ahead, one other upcoming film has been confirmed to focus on Gandalf. In an interview with Empire, screenwriter Philippa Boyens confirmed two film concepts have been within the works. One was The Hunt for Gollum, the opposite was one other Gandalf-focused story.
Evidently, the franchise is seeking to return to its roots with upcoming cinematic films. Nonetheless, counting on nostalgia with not sufficient unique concepts could be a burden. The Hobbit managed to strike this steadiness properly sufficient, although among the aforementioned moments didn’t work.
A film like Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is an instance of when nostalgia turns into an excessive amount of. Hopefully, The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum manages to search out the fitting steadiness between nostalgia and an unique story. That stated, to this point, it appears it might be repeating a mistake of the franchise’s previous.