The slasher style stays alive and effectively right now, largely due to filmmakers discovering distinctive spins on the method to maintain issues feeling contemporary. Whether or not it is the time-traveling humor of Completely Killer or the extra straight brutal Terrifier movies, it has been an actual deal with to see that one of many oldest subgenres in horror is again on the upswing after a downward flip within the ’90s.
Which is why Evening of the Reaper proves to be an actual disappointment. Hailing from Superhost and The Puppetman‘s Brandon and Ryan Christensen, the film is ready in a small city that has had a number of lacking individuals instances over time. The story facilities on Deena, a school scholar who returns to the city after a private trauma.
Shortly after returning, Deena finds herself roped into serving to fill in for her finest pal by babysitting the sheriff’s son whereas he investigates a scavenger hunt of clues tied to earlier lacking individuals. Nonetheless, as he will get nearer to the reality, she can be stricken by the masked particular person chargeable for all of it.
Led by Dream Situation‘s Jessica Clement and Sanctuary‘s Ryan Robbins, Evening of the Reaper will get off to a stable begin with its retro ’80s aesthetic, slick route, and traditional slasher film opening. Sadly, regardless of its tense starting, the film by no means actually finds its stride from there.
Evening Of The Reaper’s Plot Turns into A Cavalcade Of Tropes & Gradual Pacing
There isn’t any denying {that a} good majority of slasher films these days are true to the method, although whether or not it is their total pacing or the infusion of different genres, they nonetheless overcome their familiarity to be delights. With regards to Evening of the Reaper, not solely do the Christensens get slightly too direct with the method, however they do not even achieve this in any thrilling methods.
At simply 93 minutes, the film actually might have been the identical enjoyable time as Finn Wolfhard’s Hell of a Summer time. The retro setting, the thrilling opening sequence, and a stable design for the central villain had all of the makings of a routine film.
However as soon as we meet Deena and get invested in her and Sheriff Rod’s tales, Evening of the Reaper turns into so extremely boring. The whole night time spent with the previous as she babysits Rod’s son is like one trope after one other as she’s stalked by the villain and tormented with numerous methods round the home.
…the film deserves some credit score for its main ultimate act twist.
The latter’s investigation additionally takes too lengthy to search out any type of compelling hook or stress. Maybe the film was aiming for extra of a gradual build-up than a fast-paced experience, however even then, the strain might barely be registered as a simmer as we watch for the eventual escalation and reveal of the villain’s identification.
The opposite massive drawback with Evening of the Reaper‘s story is simply how minimal the physique rely is. Regardless of its slasher trapping, we’re not given any precise kills, however most of them aren’t all that efficient, barring one properly shocking bloody loss of life.
With all of that stated, the film deserves some credit score for its main ultimate act twist. Not solely does the villain’s identification show an attention-grabbing shock, however the best way by which Deena appears to be like to show the tables on them makes the previous story an attention-grabbing setup of clues.
However even with this good twist, the film has too lots of them. Simply as we get settled into one reveal and really feel like we’re on a streamlined path to the end line, one other is available in and throws us for an additional loop that, whereas initially intriguing, begins to really feel like padding as this continues.
Christensen’s Route Is Fashionable & Genuine
Although the script and pacing is probably not one of the best, Evening of the Reaper is a handsome movie. Reuniting with Christensen’s Superhost cinematographer, Clayton Moore, the filmmaker has a number of fashionable methods up his sleeve, significantly for a few of Deena’s extra harrowing moments.
The director additionally makes the film really feel rooted in its interval setting. Past the occasional MTV or Centipede reference, the visible palette not often veers too far into feeling like a contemporary film, as all the pieces seems lit in a time-appropriate method, whereas the settings themselves are all decked out successfully.
Jessica Clement Is A Commanding Presence
Coming into one among her first main roles after co-starring in all the pieces from Gen V to Cross, Jessica Clement proves to be a star as Deena. She properly understands the emotional undercurrent that carries Deena via many of the movie, whereas the twist-filled ultimate third sees her step up for the bodily villain showdown.
Robbins equally proves to unlock the assorted layers of Sheriff Rod. Slightly than merely resting on the laurels of an officer looking down a game-playing villain, we get a tragic backstory for the character that not solely makes his actions extra attention-grabbing, but additionally all of the extra impactful when he goes rogue.
Regardless of among the higher elements of its sum, Evening of the Reaper would not actually have sufficient going for it to face other than its style counterparts. It is a pretty gradual, low-stakes journey that, regardless of its attention-grabbing ending twists, by no means has sufficient of a hook to really feel like greater than a slasher retread.
Evening of the Reaper is now streaming on Shudder.
- Launch Date
-
October 16, 2025
- Runtime
-
93 minutes
- Director
-
Brandon Christensen
- Writers
-
Bryan Christensen
- Producers
-
Justin A. Martell, Michael Peterson, David Hiatt
- The film’s ultimate act has a number of attention-grabbing plot twists.
- Jessica Clement instructions the present along with her efficiency whereas Ryan Robbins affords distinctive new layers to his acquainted character.
- The route is fashionable and genuine to its interval setting.
- The plot is missing in any main suspense or originality.
- The twists start to really feel slightly too cluttered.