2026 has some large motion pictures scheduled for a theatrical launch, amongst them a e-book adaptation that’s on its option to being essentially the most controversial of the 12 months. Guide diversifications are sometimes profitable and might even spawn franchises, reminiscent of The Starvation Video games, however others fail at bringing their supply materials to life.
2026 has a few e-book diversifications coming to the large display, amongst them Wuthering Heights. Directed by Emerald Fennell, Wuthering Heights comes from the traditional 1847 novel of the identical identify by Emily Brontë, and stars Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi.
Wuthering Heights is among the most anticipated motion pictures of 2026, but additionally one of the vital controversial, and its issues started when it was in pre-production.
Emerald Fennell’s Wuthering Heights Controversies Defined
After the success of Promising Younger Girl and Saltburn, Emerald Fennell introduced her subsequent challenge in July 2024: an adaptation of Brontë’s Wuthering Heights. Given the success of Fennell’s earlier works, there was pleasure round her adaptation of Wuthering Heights till the casting selections for the primary characters have been introduced.
In September 2024, Margot Robbie was forged as Catherine Earnshaw and Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff, and so controversy round Fennell’s Wuthering Heights started. Readers identified on social media that Heathcliff isn’t a white man, although it’s necessary to level out that Heathcliff’s origins have been debated for years, because the novel provides totally different and even contradicting clues.
What most readers and consultants appear to agree on, nevertheless, is that Heathcliff isn’t white, although some level out that the novel’s ambiguity could make means for various interpretations, together with having Jacob Elordi enjoying the character. Fennell defended Elordi’s casting in 2025 (by way of BBC Information), saying that, when she met him whereas filming Saltburn, he appeared “precisely just like the illustration of Heathcliff” within the first e-book she learn.
The casting controversy wasn’t over when the primary trailer for Wuthering Heights was revealed, which solely made the controversy and backlash even greater. The largest complaints have been the tone of the trailer and one line that reads “inspired by the best love story”, which solely confirmed to these accustomed to the e-book that main adjustments had been made to the story.
Fennell’s Wuthering Heights is already dealing with allegations of romanticizing a poisonous relationship and omitting the darkest however essential components of the novel, which alter the message and essence of the novel.
Is Wuthering Heights An Adaptation Of The Novel?
With all these controversies and adjustments, the most important query round Fennell’s Wuthering Heights film is that if it’s an adaptation of the novel or one thing else. When the challenge was introduced, it was labeled as an adaptation of Brontë’s novel, however the extra it was revealed about it, the much less it appeared like an adaptation.
Wuthering Heights is now being marketed as a “reimagining” of the novel, with Fennell defending her model in numerous interviews. Fennell advised BBC that she wished to make one thing that made her “really feel like I felt once I first learn it”, which, together with the citation marks accompanying the film’s title, factors to it being Fennell’s personal interpretation of the e-book.
1 Wuthering Heights Idea Explains The Film’s Greatest Controversy
The citation marks on the title and the adjustments to the story, based mostly purely on the trailers, have led to an attention-grabbing idea that explains Wuthering Heights’ story controversies. Fennell isn’t any stranger to twists in her motion pictures, and Wuthering Heights won’t be the exception.
The idea means that the occasions of Wuthering Heights are taking place inside Catherine’s thoughts. This is able to clarify the romantic tone of the film that’s in contrast to the one within the novel, in addition to different story particulars that don’t add up. Catherine’s ache and loneliness could possibly be driving her to insert herself on this romance narrative with Heathcliff, whereas her actuality is the whole reverse.
Because of this the film’s title is in quotations, because the viewers is seeing what Catherine has been imagining and never her actuality, and positively not what Brontë wrote. One other idea says that the film is what a reader imagines the characters and their relationship to be like, therefore the quotations and the romantic tones, although that may nonetheless be a controversial take.
Regardless of Its Controversies, Wuthering Heights Can Nonetheless Succeed
A film’s controversies can both destroy it earlier than its launch or profit it, and in Wuthering Heights’ case, it should probably be the latter. Wuthering Heights has already generated dialog on social media, which has additionally created curiosity round it, whether or not out of real curiosity or to have strong causes to not prefer it.
Wuthering Heights additionally has two sturdy lead actors who’ve been extremely fashionable in recent times – Margot Robbie with initiatives like Barbie and Jacob Elordi with Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein – and who’ve a strong fanbase that may absolutely watch the film. These are sufficient causes for Wuthering Heights to succeed, and it may be even greater if it justifies the adjustments made to the novel.
Wuthering Heights is already essentially the most controversial e-book adaptation of 2026, and whether or not that controversy grows or dies down is to be seen. Wuthering Heights will probably succeed on the field workplace and win some critics over, however the true critics, for my part, shall be those that have learn the e-book.
Supply: BBC Information.
- Launch Date
-
February 13, 2026
- Runtime
-
136 Minutes
- Director
-
Emerald Fennell
-
-
Owen Cooper
Younger Heathcliff
-
-
Alison Oliver
Isabella Linton